Ibori: The Chronicle Of The Dramatic Trial And Guilty Verdict Of A Thief

James Onanefe Ibori
By SaharaReporters, New York

During the two-day sentencing hearings for convicted former Governor James Ibori, many Nigerians crowded around the door to court 9 of Southwark Crown Court. They pushed, shouted, talked and laughed. They all wanted to be part of the big event, to be present in the courtroom to jeer or cheer the man who was facing a critical moment.

They were so desperate to get into the court that police officers had to be called to keep order. Before the police intervened, the excited Nigerian crowd simply ignored pleas to move back.
The most vociferous were those mobilized to hail Ibori. Yet, despite their rowdy show of support, Mr. Ibori sat looking glum.

He looked especially enraged when a tiny chink of light was shed on his work for the late military ruler Sani Abacha.

In 1996, US customs officials caught Ibori with $1 million in cash. To get him out of the jam, Ibori claimed the Abacha regime had employed him to advise it on anti-drug trafficking and money laundering matters. He asserted that the cash with him was the fee he received for the job. US authorities allowed Ibori to leave the US with $600,000. They said he could collect the remainder if he could show that the money was legitimate. Mr. Ibori never bothered to collect it.

Ibori’s counsel at his money laundering trial, Nicholas Purnell, QC, spent a long time portraying the former governor as the victim of poor advice by Bhadresh Gohil, Ibori’s solicitor (who is serving a seven-year sentence). Mr. Purnell also sought to depict Ibori as a hero in his home state of Delta, a man laid low by the corruption he had “done much to lessen” in Delta State once he took office.
Mr. Purnell said: “Nigeria’s nascent democracy, its society cannot be judged by the same standards as we judge our own.” That sentiment was no doubt popular with the pro-Ibori audience in the public gallery.

Former professional footballer John Fashanu was one of Ibori’s most visible supporters. He pitched up to tell the court that, had it not been for Mr. Ibori, a dozen stadiums would not have been built for the children (and ex-militants) of Delta State. Mr. Fashanu also cited the construction of an international standard shooting range as one of the former governor’s major achievements.

“Shooting was something that hadn’t been introduced to Nigeria before,” the former footballer said in what became part of the amazing legal theatre. 

Yet, the critical moment when James Ibori’s legal team had to decide the fight was lost, came two months earlier, at a very poorly-attended hearing. Even Mr. Ibori was not present that when seemingly dry and opaque legal arguments were advanced. In reality, that was when his fate was sealed.

At the said hearing, Judge Anthony Pitts ruled that the prosecution could tell the jury that James Ibori’s convictions in Britain in the early 1990s, had they been disclosed to the correct authorities, would have given grounds for his disqualification from holding office under the terms of the Nigerian constitution.

Judge Pitts came to the ruling after listening to four witness testimonies from Nigerian constitutional law experts, including Alex Izinyon, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), one of the self-proclaimed constitutional barristers in Nigeria. The legal submissions appeared a baffling affair for the British prosecutors and the judge, as the experts seemed to contradict one another.

The prosecution witnesses asserted that, unquestionably, the spirit of the Nigerian constitution held that criminals should be barred from taking office. But Ibori’s barrister Nicholas Purnell argued that the wording of the Nigerian constitution excluded offences committed outside Nigeria. Defense witnesses said that the proper process was for ordinary citizens of Nigeria to do the digging necessary to report people they believed to be unfit to hold office to the election authorities. Then a Nigerian court would have to make a decision if that conviction was relevant and if a candidate should be barred from office. They argued, in effect, that convictions for fraud outside Nigeria meant little inside the country.

However, Judge Pitts expressed some considerable astonishment at this interpretation. He decided that – as far as this case went – the spirit of the constitution was to “guarantee good governance” as it says in the opening paragraphs of the document itself. Judge Pitts was at pains to underscore that he was not making a ruling that had any effect in Nigeria itself, only on this case, and what a British juror would hear.

The question he had to ponder, however, was one that went right to the heart of Nigerian politics: “Why would a country have a constitution that allowed an international fraudster to hold high political office, even become president?”

At this ruling Ibori’s defense played their last hand. Mr. Purnell attacked from another angle by reading out the entire text of the British Rehabilitation of Offenders Act. Under the provisions of this law, after a period of time has passed after their conviction, people convicted of an offense in a UK court are entitled to consider that their legal status has returned to be as if they had never been convicted.

Mr. Ibori and his wife, Theresa, were convicted of theft in 1991; Mr. Ibori of another count of handling stolen goods in 1992. For both offences, they received a fine. The period after which they could consider those convictions “spent” was five years. Mr. Ibori was therefore entitled to have withheld the facts about his convictions when he was standing for election in 1999, Mr. Purnell contended.

Taken aback, Judge Pitts stated, “This has taken me entirely by surprise.” He ruled later that afternoon that Nigeria had set their own time period that required disclosure of offences, and that was 10 years, as stated in the constitution. Judge Pitts ruled that the prosecution could introduce this evidence into the case.

The jury, when they were sworn in, could be told by the prosecution that Mr. Ibori’s offences not only predated his move into politics, but also that, during his swearing-in, he believed there was a significant risk that he would be disqualified if the truth about him were to be known. The prosecution could therefore paint a complete a picture of James Ibori’s “rags to riches” story, and the criminality that had been employed at every stage.

To prove the charges of conspiracy on money laundering, the prosecution needed only prove an inference of a predicate offence, such as an unexplained “rags to riches” story. Clearly, this had a chilling effect on the Ibori team.

At the court’s next hearing, it was palpable that something was clearly different. Fewer of the defense hangers-on were on the back bench of the legal benches. Their places were taken up by the detectives who had spent 7 years on the Ibori case. They seemed upbeat, and there was a happy buzz around the prosecution benches.

There had been stories in the Nigerian media of a “plea bargain” – a concept that does not have any legal validity in the UK. However, the lead prosecutor, Sasha Wass, QC, disclosed that the prosecution had made some amendments to the indictments, and that Mr. Ibori would enter a plea to the amended indictments. Afterwards, Mr. Ibori stood up and, looking at a sheaf of papers held by his lawyer, bent to read the charges as they were read to him. Out of 14 charges, he he plead guilty to 10; four were “left on the file,” which means that they would not be tried, but Ibori’s guilt was implied by his admission to the others.

“The admission accepted by the defense by this plea is to the entirety of the prosecution’s case,” said Miss Wass.

The prosecution could not only show the “irresistible inference of criminality” needed to prove the bare minimum of a charge of conspiracy to money laundering, they could prove the original, the predicate, offences of fraud in Nigeria.

But it was not until the sentencing that the public gallery got the full run-down of some of the key evidence. The court heard how, in Ibori’s first term, he took money from inflated contracts for a sports stadium and a fleet of cars for the state government, funneled the cash through shell companies in the names of his sister, Christine Ibori Ibie, and his mistress, Udoamaka Okoronkwo, and bought property in London.

In 2005, Ibori met the Mayfair solicitor Bhadresh Gohil, who the prosecution described as a “money laundering specialist;” things changed. As the money laundering reporting officer at the firm Arlington Sharmas, Gohil’s duties included keeping the firm compliant with international money laundering regulations. But Gohil would offer his services to James Ibori to hide money coming out of Delta State in ways that police admit would be hard to crack.

Gohil was introduced to Ibori by then Governor Victor Attah of Akwa Ibom, the court heard. Attah and Gohil had come up with a scam guaranteed to net them millions of dollars. The court heard how a stroke of good fortune and observant police work led to the discovery of the bulk of the evidence that made the prosecution’s case so strong. By 2005, police had begun to investigate Ibori and Gohil after their attempt to buy a private jet from the Canadian firm Bombardier raised suspicions.

A police officer searching Gohil’s office noticed that something about the electric fireplace was not right. It was, in fact, a secret compartment accessed by pulling a hidden chain. Inside was a plastic bag holding two external hard drives. They were full of data relating to what became known as the “V Mobile” fraud.

In essence, the scam was to siphon off cash from the sale of shares in the company V Mobile held by both Delta and Akwa Ibom states. To do this, the prosecution said, the conspirators created a fake “parasite” company that extracted a $37 million from the sale in fees for researching the market price, due diligence and legal work, and a success fee. The high value of the fee was justified in the sale contracts because of the supposed risks involved in the sale.

“In reality,” Judge Pitts said, “there was no risk, it was money for nothing.” Ibori, Attah, and Gohil knew the price they were likely to get from the sale and rigged it so they could extract a maximum from the deal for themselves.

One piece of evidence on the hard drives in particular linked Gohil and Ibori to the fraud. It was an email from Gohil to Ibori setting out the scheme and the steps they needed to take to carry it out. It laid out the need to create a paper trail to make the “parasite” company appear to be genuine. The proceeds were then funneled through companies and trusts in the UK Channel Islands and the Seychelles and to bank accounts in Barclays and HSBC in London and Citi Bank in the US.

Recovery procedures to locate and seize the cash will begin later this year.   

In addition to the V Mobile fraud, Gohil also helped Ibori in his attempt to buy the $20 million challenger jet. Gohil set up a Swiss bank account and then moved the money into another Swiss account belonging to a client he had power of attorney over, and who had no idea of what was going on. That “clean” money could then be used to open new accounts and buy the jet.

Despite all this evidence, Ibori’s supporters outside the court were not convinced. “All of this is not true,” one lady shouted. “He was a successful business man before becoming governor.” She refused to disclose her name.

Another man, who gave his name as Evans Johns, attended most of the hearings and was seen as a link between the supporters and the legal team. He was observed taking the roll of Ibori’s supporters who turned up.

“This judge doesn’t know the way we do things in Delta State,” Mr. Johns argued. He added, “If you showed [Judge Pitts} a map, he wouldn’t even know where Delta State was.”

Judge Pitts told the court as he sentenced Ibori: “None of the sentencing guidelines even get close to the amounts in your case. In my view had you not changed your plea to guilty you would have been at or close to the most serious sentences.” Ibori received a 13-year sentence, but will most likely serve at least seven years in jail, according to UK prison authorities.

The police have frozen £50 million of his assets. They believe they can locate another £200 million, but the true extent of what remains hidden is unknown. One report has Ibori’s loot as high as $3 billion.

That raises the question: Could Ibori come out of jail a billionaire? “He wouldn’t be the first to hide money from the courts,” concluded Detective Superintendent Matthew Parkes.

 

Comments
30 comment(s)
Post a comment

Monkey that why u are exactly

Monkey that why u are exactly where u are ,his fathers money or yours how can any right thinking person justify this may u perish in ur penury

Nigeria: A Failed State.

Nigeria is a failed state. I'm a Nigerian - born American. From now on, I'm a full - fledged African American. The country of my birth does not exist to me anymore.

Why is Attah not charged

Attah was part of the V Mobile deal . Why is that thief left free. The evidence in this case is enough for Nigerian authorities to investigate him. Truly it was not Ibori that was on trial but Nigeria and our warp values. Imagine hustler Fashanu talking nonsense and Iziyon one of these SANs that destroyed Nigerian judiciary fooling himself . It is a pity

re:

Guilty verdicts on nine counts of indecent assault on seven women.Now i feel
guilty for having bought the car.
Click www.n8fan.net for more information.

MARIZ
www.n8fan.net

A T T ... !

JO IBORI---AFRICAN THIEF THIEF ...! THERE ARE OTHERS NOW IN NIGERIA AND THE JUDGES HERE ARE TOO GENTLE TO DEAL WITH THEM. WE RELY ON ANGLO- AMERICAN JUDICIARY TO HELP US. GOD BLESS HIS TRUELY LORDSHIP, THE HON MR JUSTICE ANTHONY PITTS OF SOUTHWARK COURT, LONDON. I UNILATERALLY APPOINT HIM THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF AFRICA...!

A T T ... !

JO IBORI---AFRICAN THIEF THIEF ...! THERE ARE OTHERS NOW IN NIGERIA AND THE JUDGES HERE ARE TOO GENTLE TO DEAL WITH THEM. WE RELY ON ANGLO- AMERICAN JUDICIARY TO HELP US. GOD BLESS HIS TRUELY LORDSHIP, THE HON MR JUSTICE ANTHONY PITTS OF SOUTHWARK COURT, LONDON. I UNILATERALLY APPOINT HIM THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF AFRICA...!

ibori the thief

Mr Delta and and all the other groups fighting for the emancipation of the delta region blame the federal government for the under-development of the region but then portray ibori as a saint. Development will come when you have an hausa man as governor because ibori is the lion of delta .......i dey laugh ooooh confusion blind eye, they have eyes but cannot see

IBORI OLE! OLE!! THIEF! THIEF!!

Shut ya mouth you foolish supporters of Ibori,you're only saying good things about him because when he comes out of jail,you think he will award you all with contractS. Contract will kill you all,you think Nigeria belongs to a set of animals. Nemesis will catch up with you all one day. JUST WAIT.
OLODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO'S

IBORI IS A GOOD MAN

The man has pleaded guilty
and you are there saying
he's notm. see how stupid we
nigerians can be

The whole of ur family linage

The whole of ur family linage are very sub human.

HRH A GOAT?

Actually I am a sheep.

ibori case

Heart aches

Thief James Onanefe(are these riches?) Ibori.

HRH u re a goat! U n T-fire(Thief Fire) re probably related 2 that heartless thief whom with is unicorn headed brother stole Delta State treasury blind. Do u kno what's $290m? Emekpa!

U re right

Nagodi Saad, first step 2 solving a problem is realising d problem. There,s somthing definitely wrong with d black race.

Is someone reading all this?hope so!

Well,Would you like to turn on your computer and enter into a world created by you, a perfect home page with a powerful search engine, with the latest news on the topics you're interested, messages from your friends and family, the best deals on the internet and then your favorite games, video, chat, links to your favorite sites, shopping and many many others content, chosen by you?
You'll become part of the greatest family on the Web (The WazzUB Family over 6 Million people already joined) and be the protagonist of the greatest technological innovation on the Internet.
And that's not all, by using our free home page "perfectinter.net" as the default home page on your PC, you can also earn bonus and deal points that you can use like cash for shopping on the internet for FREE.
And if you invite your friends to join our community, the points will increase and they are given to you every single month for life.
Click to join
http://signup.wazzub.info/?lrRef=9bfa7

you lack capacity the issue

you lack capacity the issue at hand. keep your ignorance - once you define the purpose of governance you would appreciate that he has done nothing extraordinary!!! Go online and research on how Shfield council in UK will be spending over twenty five to rebuild its infrastructure - but you wont hear them screaming about it!!

Fashanu should keep quiet

Can somebody call John Fashanu to order? He should go to his state and heap praises on his governor, all south west governors are trying their best with the little resources at their disposal to develop their states but here is Ibori turning Delta state from an oil producing state to to a poverty producing state, Ibori is down Uduaghan is next in line to go to prison, God bless the U.K authorities

London Trained Theif

So, is the court comfirming that Ibori Onanefe was trained in London as a professional theif? Which enabled him to loot Nigeria's Delta State funds that was given to him as the governor for dvelopment?

FOOL! FOOL!! FOOL!!!

Fool! Fool!! Fool!!! How many times did I called you? You felt u know so much but you are just a senior and confirmed FOOL. Ibori was not convicted base on the offence he committed against Delta state but against UK. Maybe you should have gone to the UK to testify for Ibori. Maybe Judge Pitts would have listen to you and release Ibori to you, FOOL!!!

Ibori's case

Poeple should not Rejoice over Ibori's case.Rether pray for him.And we should also pray for our self's so that,we dont fall in to such temptation.

WE DONT HAVE THE SAME STANDARDS!

BLACK PEOPLE ARE SUB-HUMAN. THAT IS THE FACT, SO ANYBODY TRYING TO UNDERSTAND HOW HUMANS WILL ALLOW AN INTERNATIONAL FRAUDSTER TO BE GOVERNOR, MUST REMOVE THE TERM "HUMAN" FROM THE ARGUMENT IN ORDER TO COME TO TERMS WITH THE TRUTH. I HAVE NO DOUBT THAT SOONER OR LATER SCIENTISTS WILL FIND SOMETHING THAT SETS US APART FROM THE OTHER RACES.

Ibori is not alone!

Judge Anthony Pitts ruled that "the prosecution could tell the jury that James Ibori’s convictions in Britain in the early 1990s, had they been disclosed to the correct authorities, would have given grounds for his disqualification from holding office under the terms of the Nigerian constitution."

“Why would a country have a constitution that allowed an international fraudster to hold high political office, even become president?”

I am asking, 'why would a country that has a constitution allow its President to continue in office even though he has not declared his asset?'

Is Mr. Goodluck not threading the same path as Ibori?

Mr Pitts, the stark reality in Nigeria is that our constitutional demands are treated as verbiage by those in positions of Authority and no one can challenge them, for they are simply above the law!

That is our own understanding of democracy.

VANITY UPON VANITY!!

To all looters of our commonwealth,pay Ibori a visit in jail,he will tell you that he is ready to pay any amount for freedom.At the end of the day,Ibori will still leave all that loot and answer th call of nature one day(DEATH).
After that,history will keep his name permanently where it belongs...in the refuse bin.

Ibori remains a Hero,the Lion of Delta state.

Ibori was a man who did his best for Deltans,his developemental projects are there to show for.Ibori built numerous bridges,roads,hospitals,schoolsstadium,markets etc.Ibori touched the lives of many when he was Governor of Delta state.He's just been victimized because he was ambitious that's just d fact.the truth about Ibori will surely be told someday.

Ibori was a man who did his

Ibori was a man who did his best for Deltans,his developemental projects are there to show for.Ibori built numerous bridges,roads,hospitals,schoolsstadium,markets etc.Ibori touched the lives of many when he was Governor of Delta state.He's just been victimized because he was ambitious that's just d fact.the truth about Ibori will surely be told someday.

Ibori the Lion of Delta State !

Ibori was a man who did his best for Deltans,his developemental projects are there to show for.Ibori built numerous bridges,roads,hospitals,schoolsstadium,markets etc.Ibori touched the lives of many when he was Governor of Delta state.He's just been victimized because he was ambitious that's just d fact.the truth about Ibori will surely be told someday.

What?

Guys stop making it seems like all the other leaders in Nigeria are not equally like or worse than Ibori.

crap

Pitts was racist and you know it. He denied Ibori equal protection of the law..this is what we get as blacks in a british courts discrimination. The law rehabilitation of Ex Offenders Act 74 : s 4.1 ckearly states if that time has been spent then the slate is wiped clean. I also attended that hearing and heard the judge say it didnt apply to Ibori as he is Nigerian and he took office in Nigeria.if its spent its spent period whether you go back to the States or stay in London or wherever. He had to deny him otherwise he would have no grounds to publically humiliate the man or blacks.

That act goes on to say that you dont even have to disclose it to anyone that you have a record. If in a job and its discovered and you are fired you can claim unfair dismissal sayeth the Act.(!)

Ibori remains the Lion of Delta State .

Ibori is facing all this trials because he was over ambitious not because he stole.The british court has no right to try Ibori for crimes they alleged he committed in Delta State.Ibori did a lot of developemental projects when he was Governor and changed the lives of many.One day the truth will come out.

Some set of nigerians have

Some set of nigerians have the perchant to over flog issues to their own detriment. Madoff the American who stole over 50b is resting his ass in jail. Its over and done with. Not in Nigeria. Thank God the PDP is the only party which has been sending her thieves to jail. Let us wait and see when such will happen in saintly parties like CPC and ACN. Ibori is in the past. Just like when Al Mustapha told Nigerians that he use to flog the younger brother to great Ogboru in prison because he was caught on many occasion smuggling hard drugs into the prison for inmates. I was shocked to know that Ogboru was a drug baron on the run from IBB. Dotun Oloto and the Yoruba group who want to leave Tinubu to chase Ibori in delta state a none yoruba area, should wait for the verdict on Daniel of Ogun state, Iyabo and tinubu before he throws his own stone at us in delta.